メインコンテンツへスキップ

Memo: The answer to "more advanced" varies depending on the context, so let's organize it along three axes.

    The answer to "more advanced" for Yaskawa Electric's servo motors varies depending on the context, so let's organize it along three axes.

    In conclusion, in terms of pure technical specifications, Yaskawa is still world-class, and there are no players that clearly "surpass" it. However, there are areas where it is definitely being caught up with or overtaken in terms of domain and market.

    1. High-end technical specifications (motor + encoder + control algorithm)

    Here, Yaskawa (Σ-X series, 26-bit encoder, approximately 67 million divisions), Mitsubishi Electric (MELSERVO-J5, increased speed by increasing the number of magnetic poles to 6), FANUC (β/α series, integrated with its own CNC), Siemens (SINAMICS S210), Bosch Rexroth, and Kollmorgen (AKM2G, competing on drive and motor compatibility) are competing at the same level. Yaskawa Electric's Σ-X series encoder resolution of 26 bits is considered the highest level in the industry, and in terms of raw specifications of flagship models, Yaskawa is either ahead or at least on par. There is no company that is "clearly superior."

    The difference lies in control software, communication protocols, and peripheral ecosystems. Here, Siemens (integration with TIA Portal) and Beckhoff (the originator of EtherCAT + TwinCAT) are widely regarded in the industry as having more sophisticated engineering environments than Yaskawa. This is where Japanese companies are weak. Their weakness lies not in the motor itself, but in the "software environment for manufacturing the equipment."

    1. Competitiveness in the Chinese Market (Volume Zone)

    The situation has changed here. In the 2022 Chinese servo market, Shenzhen's Huichuan Technology (Inovance) was number one with 15.9%, followed by Yaskawa with 11.9%, Taida with 8.9%, Panasonic with 8.8%, and Mitsubishi with 8.3%. Huichuan is already the sole leader. Furthermore, recent reports indicate that Yaskawa Electric's orders from China for the June-August 2024 quarter were approximately 60% of their peak level two years prior, primarily due to replacement by Huichuan products. The situation on the ground is that Huichuan's SV660 is encroaching on the Σ-7 in terms of "price, delivery time, and service."

    What's crucial here is that Huichuan is no longer merely a low-end replacement; it has risen to a position where it is "fully usable and cost-effective." The adoption of Huichuan SV660 in a Vietnamese automotive parts factory and the beginning use of KuntaiXin's KTM58 encoder in German factory equipment demonstrate that this is no longer just a domestic Chinese issue. This represents a structural loss of market share.

    1. Next-Generation Areas (Collaborative Robots, Humanoids, Direct Drives)

    In the realm of small, high-power-density, hollow-shaft, low-heat servos for humanoid robots, there is a segment where harmonic drives combined with dedicated servos are used. Kollmorgen (frameless), Maxon (Switzerland, precision miniatures), and TQ-Group (Germany) have unique strengths in this area. Among Chinese companies, Unitree and Xiaomi are rapidly developing their own servos for humanoid robots. While Yaskawa is strong in industrial robots, small, high-density servos for humanoid robots are not currently their main battleground.

    To summarize:

    No company "clearly surpasses" Yaskawa in terms of individual component specifications.

    Siemens/Beckhoff leads in system integration and software environments.

    In China, Yaskawa has lost its top position in market share and price-performance ratio to Huichuan (Inovance).

    In the next-generation humanoid/collaborative field, Kollmorgen, Maxon, and emerging Chinese companies are making inroads.

    Yaskawa's real risk is not "losing in technology," but rather a structural one: "Having lost the mid-range market to Huichuan, it will no longer be able to maintain profits solely through its high-end superiority." This can be seen as following the same pattern that occurred in Japanese consumer electronics and semiconductor memory in the 1980s and 90s.

    あなたへのおすすめ