メインコンテンツへスキップ
見出し画像

Does Collecting Data Turn Pure Luck into Science?LIFE (Long-term Care Information System For Evidence): An Attempt to "Treat" Daily Living

    Phew! Finally done!


    On the night of the 10th of every month, overtime is inevitable. Even as evening falls, a mountain of data entry remains for LIFE (Long-term Care Information System For Evidence). If the data isn't transmitted before Cinderella's clock strikes midnight, we fail the criteria for additional billing reimbursements. The system logs the exact timestamp of initial submission, so missing the deadline simply isn't an option.

    Next to me, my partner is sweating bullets while hammering away at the keyboard. He’s the most competent care worker we have, helping me with this task—spending almost his entire working hours over the past four or five days on LIFE.

    As I punch in numbers and check boxes, the "Banana Boat Song" starts looping in my head. You know the one: "Day-o, Day-ay-ay-o..."

    The Scientific Long-term Care Information System. A mechanism introduced into Japan’s long-term care insurance system in 2021.
    It is neither scientific nor of any informational value whatsoever. It is that kind of system.

    Why?
    Because the data is garbage.
    Proof complete. Q.E.D.

    Let's test this premise. Why do I consider the data we are inputting right now to be garbage?

    (1) There is no way to verify whether the assessor’s evaluation is accurate. Their clinical assessment could simply be mistaken.

    (2) Whoever inputs the data might make mistakes during entry.

    (3) It is unclear whether data entered once a month or once every three months reflects reality at all. In addition to potential assessment errors mentioned in (1), frontline staff, desperate to lessen their workload, may well "tweak" prior entries just enough so they look plausible before sending them off.

    (4) With so many fluctuating items —-- such as disease diagnoses and prescription names —-- it is impossible to ensure they are properly tracked and updated. Besides, as long as something is entered, it passes downstream without any subsequent verification.

    (5) Official audits by local government authorities can do little more than confirm "whether data was submitted or not."

    I have been through three official administrative audits regarding LIFE. The first time, the inspector didn't even look at the content, merely advising: "Make sure you keep inputting it properly." The second time, the auditor opened the laptop but didn't know how to navigate the software, and time simply ran out. By the third time, an official finally showed up who knew how to check the entries. Yet, even when they can check that the data exists, they never verify whether that data is valid or true.

    There are no rewards for inputting accurate data, nor penalties for entering nonsense; there is not even a way to verify mere perfunctory entries. In terms of long-term care reimbursement fees, it barely covers the cost of manual labor. Given all this, believing that trustworthy data is being accumulated is absurd.

    Some might ask: "Doesn't it offer self-evaluation through system feedback reports?" When printing a feedback summary for a mere 100 residents takes half a working day, what care facility on earth has time to actually use it?

    As a result, our most capable frontline staff spend entire days doing mind-numbingly simplistic, utterly unproductive data entry, transmitting it all while knowing full well that it is garbage.

    Since the earliest days of computer science, there has been an adage: "Garbage In, Garbage Out (GIGO)." It means that if you feed in meaningless data, you will only get meaningless results.


    To begin with, what does "scientific nursing care" even mean? We have to examine this from first principles.

    What long-term care supports is daily living (life itself).

    Looking at the legal definition under Japanese law, the duties of a Certified Care Worker are defined as providing assistance to "individuals who face difficulties in conducting daily life." (Article 2, Paragraph 2 of the Certified Social Worker and Certified Care Worker Act: "A Certified Care Worker refers to a person who, as a profession, provides care tailored to the physical and mental conditions of individuals who face difficulties in conducting daily life due to physical or mental disabilities, and who provides guidance regarding care to such individuals and their caregivers.")

    By contrast, what do medicine and nursing support? Dr. Takahito Takeuchi offered an insightful analysis on this:

    • Medicine essentially deals with illness, though it also addresses impairment.

    • Nursing deals with impairment, while sharing its focus across illness and daily living.

    • Care work (Kaigo) essentially deals with daily living, while interfacing with impairment.
      (Takahito Takeuchi, Basic Science of Care Work, Ishiyaku Publishers, 1998, pp. 8–9)

    Medicine handles illness, nursing handles disability/impairment, and care work handles daily living --- with natural overlaps occurring where needed. This is the overarching architecture of care services.

    Furthermore, throughout the history of social welfare, a major evolutionary theme has been the transition from the "medical (hospital) model" to the "social (living) model."

    Housing individuals with intellectual disabilities in massive, segregated institutions was a clear manifestation of the medical model.

    In the early days of special nursing homes for the elderly, care routines resembled hospital wards: residents were kept bedridden all day, and staff turned their bodies every two hours. However, under that regimen, practically everyone developed bedsores. By moving closer to a "normal daily life" —-- getting out of bed in the morning, getting dressed, going to the dining hall, dining with others, and spending the majority of the day seated upright --- bedsores were eliminated, and residents' Quality of Life dramatically improved. (See Takahito Takeuchi, Can Medicine Encounter Daily Living?, Ishiyaku Publishers, 1995 --- an older text, but thoroughly exhilarating).

    However, as the Long-Term Care Insurance system has matured, a regressive tendency back toward the medical model has surfaced. Originally, the system itself was designed around the premise: "We provide benefits so you can get better and return home." Even in nursing homes, regulations mandate regular assessments regarding the feasibility of discharge back to the community; in the early days of the insurance system, people earnestly discussed the model of "rehabilitating in a nursing home, and once recovered, moving to a care house."

    Medical professionals tend to prefer reductionist, algorithmic thinking: "For condition X, apply treatment Y." Meanwhile, insurers seeking administrative efficiency naturally crave prospective payment schemes akin to medical DPC (Diagnosis Procedure Combination).

    And so, they attempt to "treat." To treat daily living. Through the lens of "scientific" care.

    What they consider "scientific" remains a mystery to me. Presumably, they believe collecting data is part of being scientific. But suppose someone collected data on romantic love and claimed that conforming to the statistical majority constituted "scientific romance" --- we would have to call that absurd. Anyone who has ever fallen in love understands this: once you fall for someone, you can't help it. Whether parents oppose it, neighbors find it strange, or God Himself forbids it, you cannot simply switch off love.

    Rehabilitation for older adults certainly has its merits. But if someone slips, falls, and fractures their femur, they must start over from a baseline even lower than where they began. And no matter how "scientifically" vigilant you are, when a fall happens, it happens. Whether an elderly resident regains their vitality is ultimately a matter of luck, a prayer to the heavens.

    There was a facility in our prefecture that once achieved the highest score for improving residents' care need certification levels. Given the opportunity, I quietly asked one of their staff members how they accomplished it. Their reply: "No idea. It was just sheer coincidence." That is the honest reality felt by anyone working on the frontlines of elder care.

    The domain of care is daily living, and you cannot "treat" a life.
    From the viewpoint of care work, even end-of-life palliative care is simply an integral part of living.

    If so, the mindset behind "scientific care" harbors an arrogance bordering on eugenics, showing no fear of the divine. Doesn't it trespass into territory that science cannot control --- territory where attempting to intervene with cold science is, in itself, a form of sacrilege?


    Lost in these rambling thoughts, I finished typing in the last field, bringing me back to my opening sigh: "Phew! Finally done!"

    You might wonder how someone could be pondering such complex matters while working. But honestly, it's nothing more than rote data entry. My brain was idling the entire time. Had I been reflecting on the well-being of our residents, that might have been noble of me --- but I am neither that virtuous nor that dedicated a worker.

    Before shutting down the computer, I decided to do a quick search online about scientific care once more.

    To my astonishment, I stumbled upon an invitation to a study group where academic researchers plan to conduct secondary and tertiary research studies using that exact garbage data!

    Come to think of it, computer science has another famous phrase: "Garbage In, Gospel Out." It describes the blind faith that even if the input data is junk, whatever the computer spits out must be divine gospel truth. This is no longer science; it belongs to the realm of religious faith.

    Dear researchers: please stop wrestling with someone else's loincloth (stop riding on the backs of others). Do not build your careers on cursed data soaked in the sweat, blood, and quiet resentment of frontline care workers.

    As demonstrated by Dr. Kotaro Ould Maeno in To Defeat the Locust in Africa (Kobunsha, 2024), real data is something you must go out and gather with your own two hands, with your whole heart, and at the risk of your own LIFE.

    • Note: This text is a machine translation generated using Gemini 4 Argon, reviewed by the original author, Goro Yamaguchi. The original Japanese text serves as the authoritative version.*


     
     
    介護保険の実務家|料理が好き|語学オタク(英語・独語・泰語・愛蘭語)|元セロー乗り|介護支援専門員|行政書士|介護系法律・制度の物書き|自由律俳句|Kindle出版を少し|ウクレレ|お酒好き|血圧高い|エッコ奥さんと猫2匹の下僕|どうぞ、よろしく。

    あなたへのおすすめ