| Idle, sleepless rambling about comic book heroes |
[May. 9th, 2010|04:20 am]
6ferrets
|
Well, I braved the crowds on opening night, but I don't remember Iron Man 2 quite as fondly after a night's sleep as when I first saw it. On the other hand, during a sleepless night I got to wondering who among DC's most famous heroes is the closest counterpart to Iron Man. Who among DC's most famous heroes are the closest counterparts Marvel's most famous heroes?
My impression of superheroes was mostly formed from the TV/silver screen/Internet, so it may be skewed. There may be closer matches known to comic book geeks, but I'm limiting myself to the characters that were successful enough to enter the public consciousness. Actually, I cheated a little bit. I honestly don't remember how I heard of Namor the Sub-Mariner.
MARVEL COMICS DC COMICS
Iron Man Batman
Talented human who relies on cleverness, technology, and a vast inheritance
Silver Surfer Superman
Super-powered alien, only one of his kind, adopted Earth as his home
Thor Wonder Woman
Mythological figure with divine (-ly granted) powers
Namor Aquaman
Half human, heir to the throne of Atlantis
? Flash
? Green Lantern
? Martian Manhunter
Captain America ?
Hulk ?
Spider-Man ?
Maybe I'm wrong, but Daredevil, Fantastic Four, and X-Men weren't generally well known until the 21st century movies.
Looking him up, I found that Captain Marvel was originally the most popular comic book character of all (because he was the alter ego of a twelve-year-old?). Now owned by DC, he was created by Fawcett Comics, but they were sued for making him a Superman rip-off. DC's Green Arrow (not listed above) started out as a Batman rip-off. Martian Manhunter seems to have been a combination of Batman (detective) and Superman (see above). I'm not sure how famous they really are. I just happen to be friends with arguably too many comic book fans. ;-)
What does it all mean? Um ... Marvel likes hyphens. DC doesn't. DC's heroes seem to be more "super" than Marvel's. On average, they're more powerful, glamorous, and free from mundane problems. Except for Batman, each of those DC characters should easily beat Captain America for example. Tony Stark will die without his gadgetry. Bruce Banner and Thor are cursed to be a monster and a disabled human, respectively. Peter Parker is a high school nerd who struggles for money. And so on. Prima facie, Marvel makes more complex characters. Of course, they've all been around for decades, and I'm sure they've been portrayed better or worse depending on the writer. |
|