reality blurred flame logo reality blurred Best Evidence true crime folder logoBest Evidence Made from Humans
Folder logo for Best Evidence: the true crime worth your timeBest Evidence
The true crime worth your time

True crime rewind

A random story from the archives, selected just for you!
envelope with letter

True-crime coverage in your inbox

Subscribe to Best Evidence’s newsletter:

News and updates

  • Luigi Mangione entered a guilty plea in federal court this morning, per Gothamist. Sentencing is scheduled for December 18; Mangione “faces up to life in prison for the federal crimes he pleaded guilty to, which were charges that he stalked Thompson and traveled to New York to kill him.”

    I had assumed Mangione would have no trouble seating a sympathetic jury and taking his chances therewith, but perhaps those odds dwindle the more time that passes, idk. Gothamist’s piece from yesterday talks more about the difference between the two proceedings against Mangione, state and federal, and what the federal plea could mean for the state charges.

  • A federal district judge ruled Wednesday that Alex Murdaugh “cannot seek $600,000 from former Colleton County Clerk Becky Hill to pay for his legal fees because she had nothing to do with the murder charges that were filed against him.”

  • HBO has ordered Matthew Barry’s docudrama series The Trial of Louise Woodward — about the 1997 case in which an au pair was accused of killing her infant charge. No premiere date yet, though presumably it’s next year, pinning it to the case’s 30th anniversary.

    The series will star Meghann Fahy (The Bold Type).

  • An ABC press release from last week announced the launch of “’20/20 True Crime+,’ a brand-new subscription for true crime fans worldwide,” which offers subscribers “exclusive content and early access to new series ahead of the public releases, along with archival shows from the ABC News vault.” 

    The blast also mentioned new pod series What Happened to the McStays? and Burden of Proof: Luigi Mangione.

  • From NJ.com: “A N.J. cop disguised himself as a shrub — and helped catch 74 distracted drivers in one day.” [hums TLC to self]

More true-crime stories

Exhibit B. Books

Exhibit B. is Sarah’s specialty store focusing on true-crime books and ephemera.

use code ExBlurred at checkout for 15% off

folder_open

About Best Evidence

Welcome to Best Evidence, which is devoted to the analysis, critique, and review of true-crime properties across audio, video, and text.

Now more than ever, you need a guide to what true crime is worth your time—and that’s what we’re here to do.

people

Your hosts

Sarah D. Bunting
Editor-in-chief

Sarah founded The Blotter in 2011 and was the host of its flagship podcast, The Blotter Presents. She was a cofounder of the seminal television critique site Television Without Pity; she also co-hosts podcasts including Mark and Sarah Talk About Songs, Extra Hot Great, and Again With This.

• • •

Eve Batey
Publisher

Eve Batey is (with Sarah D. Bunting) the co-founder of Best Evidence. She’s a former deputy managing editor at the San Francisco Chronicle, was once the editor of Eater SF, and is currently a contributor to Vanity Fair (among other publications). You can find her on Instagram as @evelb or send pitches, tips, and fan mail to [email protected].

🦋 Bluesky

☎️ 919-75-CRIME