musesfool: Kory from Titans (i must confess i still believe)
i did it all for the robins ([personal profile] musesfool) wrote2023-07-21 02:20 pm

Unworthy to sit at your foot or your crown

I'm supposed to go to my sister's tomorrow to help babysit Baby Miss L, but the exterminator - the reason I didn't go today - is being rescheduled (arrggh), so I texted my sister that I could come this afternoon if needed, and she's like, "wait, we may be having other guests" so...I'm waiting.

In the meantime, RIP Tony Bennett. #legends only

In other music news, Gaslight Anthem has anew song out: History Books, featuring Bruce Springsteen!

Yesterday, I watched Queen Charlotte, the Bridgerton prequel on Netflix, and I mostly enjoyed it. India Amarteifio knocks it out of the park as young Charlotte, and Arsema Thomas is fantastic as young Lady Danbury. At least once an episode I rolled my eyes at the show trying to make George III a romantic figure, but despite the tyranny, I did feel bad for him about his mental illness, which may or may not have been bipolar but was portrayed more as some kind of schizophrenia. Despite his mental health issues, he and Charlotte do have a charming romance and were allegedly devoted to each other in real life as well. I also liked that it explained some of the worldbuilding we see in the series proper, but you still can't think too hard about it or it all falls apart. Mainly, the thing I disliked was Lady Danbury having a fling with Violet Bridgerton's father, since I have been lowkey shipping them (Lady B and Lady D) for two seasons and this is kind of a fly in the ointment. I did love the different portrayals of widowhood and the women who have to live with it in a world where their main value (popping out kids) is long past. And the parallel with Charlotte, who is not actually a widow by may as well be give how little time she and George get to spend together in the narrative present/Regency era. I also enjoyed getting some of Brimsley's backstory, enough that I was really sad when they cut to him dancing without Reynolds in the present!

So if you're looking for light entertainment on a hot summer weekend, you might enjoy it.

*
poisontaster: character Wen Qing from The Untamed (Default)

[personal profile] poisontaster 2023-07-21 08:10 pm (UTC)(link)
I really enjoyed Queen Charlotte, probably more than OG Bridgerton, which I do enjoy, but shows the age of its source material, whereas Queen Charlotte was an entirely new fiction (though yes, I have to close my mind to the reality of George III as well as the flimsiness of the world building). In a number of articles after the show, because there was a LOT of outcry for Brimsley/Reynolds, they did say that Reynolds isn't dead, and we may get more of that in the future.
lunabee34: (Default)

[personal profile] lunabee34 2023-07-22 10:55 am (UTC)(link)
Awww boo. I hope you get some Baby L time.
selenak: (James Boswell)

[personal profile] selenak 2023-07-22 01:41 pm (UTC)(link)
At least once an episode I rolled my eyes at the show trying to make George III a romantic figure, but despite the tyranny, I did feel bad for him about his mental illness, which may or may not have been bipolar but was portrayed more as some kind of schizophrenia. Despite his mental health issues, he and Charlotte do have a charming romance and were allegedly devoted to each other in real life as well.

They were, despite really meeting for the first time on the day of their wedding. While Bridgerton never pretends at historical accuracy (au contraire, as their disclaimer tells), I will say that their G3 is at least as accurate as Hamilton's, because Farmer George, mental illness or not, was the least flamboyant of all the Hannovers and yes, the first faithful husband (and for a long time the last) of the clan. (Not the first husband in love of his wife. G2 was crazy about Caroline, but he did cheat on her, not least because it was socially expected of him.) As far as heroes of romance are concerned, G3 works better than the rest of his family.

(Speaking of his family, the Bridgerton version in order to heighten the importance of Charlotte conceiving an heir edits out all of G3's brothers and sisters, of which there were a lot. This includes poor Caroline Matilda, G3's youngest sister who married mentally ill King Christian of Denmark, had a love affair with his doctor-and-favourite Struensee and is the heroine of the movie with Mads Mikelsen as Struensee. The whole thing ended in tears, Struensee executed and Caroline Matilda banished to Hanover where she died just a few years later. Talk about how royal marriages could go in that era.)

Tyranny: well, due to the fact that at time time the Prime Minister and Parliament did most of the ruling already, he didn't have the chance to be much of one, compared with most of the other European monarchs. (The ones in Sweden were also constitutional monarchs, but the rest were absolute monarchs.) I mean, I know American propaganda built him up as a tyrannical figure, but I always thought this is because complaining about the tyranny of Parliament and PM just is less efficient rethoric. Which isn't to say G3 pre mental illness (which the Bridgerton version lets occur decades before it did in rl) was a champion of liberalism or equality. He liked his Tories better than his Whigs, and even young G3, when acceeding to the throne, was all offended dignity when cousin Frederick the Great (this was mid 7 Years War, in which Prussia and England were allies) sent him a letter which presumed equality (at least). But he did have a hardcore work ethic, took his responsibilities seriously, and was actually the first Hannover King to be personally popular as King (as opposed to as Prince of Wales) in his own country, which, again, is more than the majority of his contemporaries on the thrones could claim.

re: The Bridgerton version: it amuses me that the show's aesthetic goes with vaguely Georgian outre wigs for the ladies (best embodied by Charlotte herself, of course) but draws the line at wigs for the men, hence George walking around with a short modern haircut. I also thought that for the fluffy romance genre which this show is, the depiction of what in the 18th century constituted progressive treatment for the mentally ill was amazingly dark (and sad to say semi realistic - even for this particular case; most of what was done to G3 probably made things worse), and the romance between the two footmen was sweet and poignant. (Also , it's a m/m couple with actual screen time and characterisation, not just minor characters without either.)

Have you ever seen the filmed version of Alan Bennett's play, The Madness of King George? That one has Nigel Hawthorne as G3 and Helen Mirren as Charlotte, and their relationship is one of its strengths as well. (Its theory of G3's illness as porphyria is based on now outdated research, but such is life.)