by Dennis Crouch
This is a follow-up to my September post on Professor John Duffy's move to the USPTO. Duffy was sworn in as General Counsel on October 5, and the Office has now expanded his title to General Counsel and Supervisory Solicitor. Joining him as Deputy General Counsel and Solicitor is Professor Greg Dolin (Baltimore). Dolin is a former clerk for Judge Pauline Newman and later represented her in her lawsuit against Chief Judge Moore and the Federal Circuit's Judicial Council.
Duffy and Dolin are law professors and creative appellate litigators. I expect to see some interesting developments.

Duffy's first visible work product was announced on November 10, 2026. In a memorandum co-signed with Director Squires, the Office is returning the merits portion of IPR and PGR institution decisions to the PTAB, effective November 16.
The Director will keep the initial screen on discretionary and other non-merits factors. Petitions that survive go to a three-judge panel that decides institution on the merits on the Director's behalf -- and if that panel institutes, a different panel will conduct the trial. The memo also tightens the merits standard. A petition fails if it falls short on a substantial majority of the challenged claims, and a claim whose arguments are in "equipoise" counts against the petitioner. Tie goes to denial.
To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.




