Tag Archives: WesternGeco v. ION

Whole or Apportioned: Sunoco Asks the Supreme Court to Rethink Lost Profits

by Dennis Crouch

Sunoco has filed its petition for certiorari in the butane blending damages fight, asking the Supreme Court to decide whether the Federal Circuit's lost profits framework violates the "make-whole" command of 35 U.S.C. § 284, and whether the court's approach to Federal Rule of Evidence 702 lets trial judges resolve fact disputes that belong to juries. Sunoco Partners Marketing & Terminals L.P. v. Powder Springs Logistics, LLC, No. 25-1387. The petition challenges Judge Stoll's decision affirming Judge Richard Andrews' exclusion of Sunoco's entire damages presentation. Sunoco Partners Marketing & Terminals L.P. v. Powder Springs Logistics, LLC, Nos. 2023-1218, 2023-1274 (Fed. Cir. Jan. 16, 2026) (non-precedential).

Last month I listed this case among six placeholder petitions awaiting the Court and called it a companion to Finesse Wireless LLC v. AT&T Mobility LLC, No. 25-953, Paul Clement's Seventh Amendment challenge to the same expert-testimony regime. Dennis Crouch, Six Petitions, Six Placeholders: The Patent Docket Awaiting the Supreme Court, Patently-O (June 8, 2026). But that companion case was recently denied certiorari.

Petroleum storage tank farm terminal, the point-of-distribution setting for automated butane blending into gasoline

A Delaware jury found three Sunoco patents willfully infringed and awarded $12 million, a figure built by multiplying two cents royalty per gallon of blended butane. Sunoco's damages expert, Dr. Keith Ugone, was prepared to tell the jury that lost profits ran to $150 million or more, and infringer had (allegedly) profited by more than $300 million. The jury never heard any of that profit testimony. Judge Andrews excluded the expert testimony because it did not apportion-out the value of non-patented services bundled into those deals, leaving the defense's two-cent figure as the only number in the courtroom.

The petition presents two questions:


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Seeds of Doubt: Sexual Reproduction and Territorial Limits in Plant Patent Law

by Dennis Crouch

Driscoll's operates as the world's largest berry company, controlling about one-third of the $6 billion U.S. berry market.  For the most part, however, Driscoll's does not grow the berries itself, but rather develops new varieties and then licenses their use through local farmers across dozens of countries. These agreements include anti-breeding provisions layered on top of their plant patent rights.

The defendant in this case, California Berry Cultivars, LLC (CBC), was founded by Dr. Doug Shaw, a former UC Davis professor who led the university's strawberry breeding program for decades.  In 2017 Shaw was found liable for infringing several UC Davis strawberry patents.  During the UC litigation, some documents apparently revealed that CBC had used Driscoll's varieties in their breeding programs.

Driscoll then sued Shaw and CBC for infringement of their patents.  PP 18,878; PP 22,247; and PP 23,400. Ultimately, however, the district court sided with the accused infringer -- granting summary judgment based upon Driscoll’s failed to produce sufficient evidence that patented plants were specifically used as maternal plants (i.e., the plant bearing the seeds) in the crosses, or that any seeds derived from patented plants were imported or used within the United States.


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Pending En Banc Petitions at the Federal Circuit

by Dennis Crouch

The Federal Circuit recently decided the en banc design patent case of LKQ v. GM, but the court has not issued an en banc decision in a utility patent case since 2018.  There are currently four interesting petitions pending before the court.


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Guest post by Prof. Holbrook: Extraterritoriality and Patent Damages Under § 271(a)

Guest post by Tim Holbrook. Robert B. Yegge Endowed Distinguished Professor of Law and Provost's Professor, University of Denver Sturm College of Law.

United States patents are generally territorial.  Their exclusive rights only operate within the United States and its territories.  Or so one may think reading the Patent Act.  Moreover, in a global marketplace, the territorial nature of intellectual property rights can create challenges. It would be simpler for a patent holder to just use the U.S. patent to cover foreign activity. This is especially true if a domestic act of infringement has spillover effects into other countries.

So, when – if ever – can a patent owner receive damages for foreign activity that may flow from acts of domestic infringement?

The Supreme Court answered that question  


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.