Tag Archives: Reasonable Royalty

royalty base and rate, Georgia-Pacific, comparable licenses

The Federal Circuit Edits Its Damages Footnote in Constellation Designs v. LG

by Dennis Crouch

The Federal Circuit today reissued its panel decision in Constellation Designs, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 2024-1822 (Fed. Cir. Aug. 31, 2026), four months after the original April 28 opinion.  But, the court did not follow the rehearing path suggested by the adjudged infringer LG, and the April panel decision stands unchanged:

  • The "optimization" claims of US8842761 and US10693700 are ineligible under § 101;
  • The "constellation" claims of US11019509 and US11018922 are eligible;
  • The infringement verdict stands (denial of JMOL was proper); and
  • The $1.7 million past royalty and $6.75 per television ongoing royalty stand.

What moved in the rehearing decision was just a footnote. The April opinion gave two reasons for leaving the damages award alone even though five of the nine asserted claims are headed toward a judgment of ineligibility. The first was forfeiture. The second was that Constellation's damages expert had testified that the value of the asserted patents was tied to the technology rather than to any of the particular asserted patents or claims, and that no LG witness disputed that testimony. LG's rehearing petition pointed to that testimony to argue that no apportionment ever happened. Valuing the technology instead of the asserted claims is the thing Garretson and its descendants forbid, and the panel converted that concession into the reason the award could survive the loss of five claims. LG went on to argue that its lack of rebuttal testimony was irrelevant because the damages theory was deficient on its face.

The rehearing petition asked the court to vacate the opinion and reverse the denial of judgment as a matter of law of no damages, or in the alternative to remand for damages proceedings on the surviving claims.  The court did not do any of these. It simply deleted the sentence regarding "technology based damages" for patent infringement, the sentence that would have supported infringement damages not tied appropriately to the patents being infringed. The result then is that the holding stands on forfeiture and says nothing about whether a single undifferentiated royalty survives the loss of half the asserted claims.

Here is the edit, with deleted text struck through:

During oral argument, LG argued for the first time that if we determine—as we do here—that some asserted claims are patent ineligible, we should vacate the damages award. See Oral Arg. 18:03–19:34, 42:44–45:38. This argument was foreseeable and should have been raised in LG's opening brief. See, e.g., ABS Glob., Inc. v. Cytonome/ST, LLC, 984 F.3d 1017, 1027 (Fed. Cir. 2021) (collecting cases for proposition that arguments raised for the first time during oral argument are forfeited). Even so, Constellation's damages expert, Dr. Sullivan, testified that the value of Constellation's asserted patents was tied to the technology rather than any asserted patent or claim, J.A. 20280 (Trial Tr. 42:11–23) (testimony of Dr. Sullivan), and none of LG's witnesses disputed this testimony. Cf. J.A. 20333 (Trial Tr. 256:3–16) (testimony of Mr. Lewis acknowledging that the Zenith licenses were similarly tied to the technology rather than any patents or claims).


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Value From the Beginning: The Book of Wisdom’s Limit in 4DD Holdings v. United States

by Dennis Crouch

The Federal Circuit's new decision in 4DD Holdings, LLC v. United States, No. 2024-1996 (Fed. Cir. July 16, 2026) is a copyright case that runs almost entirely on patent damages doctrine.

The unanimous opinion authored by Judge Hughes affirmed that the Court of Federal Claims (CFC) could fix the government's liability for infringing 4DD's TETRA healthcare-data software through a hypothetical negotiation rather than simply using the rates in the parties' prior license. But, the court still vacated the $12.7 million award based upon overuse of what courts call the "book of wisdom" and the lack of enhanced statutory damages available for infringement actions against the United States. The court remanded for a fresh damages analysis.

4DD May 2013 quote for 64 TETRA Federator cores showing a $24,000 per-core list price and a $10,446.61 volume price

The dispute grew out of the Defense Department's effort to make military and veterans' health records talk to one another. The government bought TETRA through a reseller, licensing 64 processing cores and 50 user seats, and then, through its lead contractor, made thousands of unauthorized copies while adapting the software for its secure networks. The Court of Federal Claims found the government had exceeded its license by 290,000 cores and 170,000 seats.

4DD asked the court to apply its list prices copy by copy, which would have put damages in the billions. The trial court instead constructed a hypothetical negotiation and awarded $12,683,065.86.


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

The Unjust Enrichment Option: A Trade Secret Plaintiff’s Choice of Remedy

by Dennis Crouch

A trade secret plaintiff's willingness to license its secret does not limit future recovery to a reasonable-royalty measure.  In Versata Software, LLC v. Ford Motor Co., Nos. 2024-1140 (Fed. Cir. May 22, 2026), the court found that the plaintiff may still recover under alternative damages theories, such as the defendant's unjust enrichment.

Our various trade secrecy statutes provide for both actual-loss damages and also for unjust state and federal trade secret statutes provide several alternative damages calculation approaches.  The DTSA, for example allows for both:

(I) damages for actual loss caused by the misappropriation of the trade secret; and

(II) damages for any unjust enrichment caused by the misappropriation of the trade secret that is not addressed in computing damages for actual loss.

The statute goes on to state that one alternative form of damages may be "imposition of liability for a reasonable royalty for the misappropriator’s unauthorized disclosure or use of the trade secret." 18 U.S.C. § 1836(b)(3)(B).

Versata was litigated under the Michigan Uniform Trade Secrets Act, which provides parallel remedy language.  Notably, both statutes authorize unjust enrichment recovery as a matter of statutory right.  On appeal, the Federal Circuit found the lower court erred by preventing the unjust enrichment recovery.  The court also reversed the district court's reduction of an $82.26 million breach-of-contract award down to $3 and reinstated the jury's number.

Ford hired Versata (then Trilogy) to develop vehicle-configuration software, licensed two products under a 2004 Master Subscription and Services Agreement (MSSA), and then, when renewal talks broke down in 2014, released its own configuration software that Ford had developed while still licensing Versata's product. As things came to a head, Ford sued first, seeking a declaratory judgment that it had neither infringed Versata's patents nor misappropriated its trade secrets. Versata answered with counterclaims for misappropriation under the DTSA and MUTSA, asserting three interdependent "combination" trade secrets along with a breach-of-contract claim under the MSSA.

The doctrinally interesting work, though, is on remedies, and it turns almost entirely on the structure of the statutory damages provisions.


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

An Inexact Art: Willis Electric and the Limits of Damages Gatekeeping

by Dennis Crouch

For the past year, the Federal Circuit has been systematically tightening the screws on patent damages and particularly pro-patentee expert testimony on the issue. Beginning with EcoFactor, Inc. v. Google LLC, 137 F.4th 1333 (Fed. Cir. 2025), the court vacated a $20 million reasonable royalty award for insufficient apportionment. Then came Jiaxing Super Lighting Electric Appliance Co. v. CH Lighting Technology Co., 146 F.4th 1098 (Fed. Cir. 2025), where the court vacated another award and suggested (in dicta) that experts must quantify their Georgia-Pacific adjustments. LabCorp v. Qiagen reversed a jury verdict on similar grounds. Coda Development v. Goodyear Tire "deflated" a $64 million award for inadequate apportionment. See Dennis Crouch, The Remedies Remedy is Almost Complete: EcoFactor v. Google, Patently-O (May 22, 2025); Dennis Crouch, Federal Circuit Extends EcoFactor Framework to Patent Damages Apportionment in Jiaxing Decision, Patently-O (Aug. 1, 2025); Dennis Crouch, Verdict Deflated: Fed Circuit Punctures Coda's $64M Win Over Goodyear, Patently-O (Dec. 8, 2025). The cumulative message to patentees seemed pretty clear: jury verdicts on damages face appellate scrutiny, and experts who failed to satisfy the court's increasing expectations would have their testimony excluded and the resulting awards overturned.

Today's decision in Willis Electric Co., Ltd. v. Polygroup Ltd., No. 2024-2118 (Fed. Cir. Feb. 17, 2026), suggests there is a limit. Writing for a unanimous panel, Chief Judge Moore affirmed a jury's $40+ million reasonable royalty award on a single dependent claim covering coaxial barrel connectors used in pre-lit artificial Christmas trees. The opinion runs to 37 pages, with the bulk devoted to a comprehensive defense of the damages verdict under Rule 702 and Daubert. The court upheld every challenged aspect of the patentee's expert testimony: her income-based apportionment, her market-based apportionment using comparable licenses, and her qualitative application of the Georgia-Pacific factors. Where EcoFactor drew a line against expert testimony predicated on inaccurate factual premises, Willis Electric draws a line in the other direction. It holds that methodological choices about how to model profitability, which licenses to consider comparable, and how to weigh qualitative factors are matters for cross-examination and jury deliberation, not judicial exclusion. The repeated refrain of the opinion is that reasonable royalty calculations "necessarily involve an element of approximation and uncertainty," EcoFactor, 137 F.4th at 1340, and Rule 702 must accommodate that reality.

For many years, I have seen the reasonable royalty "calculation" as a form of speculative science fiction. It is filled with such uncertainty that attempts for mathematical precision simply mask what is fundamentally a rough estimation exercise. The hypothetical negotiation is a legal fiction built on counterfactual assumptions, and the Georgia-Pacific factors provide structure without providing answers. Courts and experts have long struggled with how much rigor to demand from an inherently imprecise inquiry.

In Willis Electric, Chief Judge Moore engages with that tension directly, and several passages seem destined for heavy citation in future damages disputes. The court's core distinction is between (1) an expert who builds on erroneous factual premises -- ones that are "contrary to a critical fact upon which the expert relied" (the EcoFactor problem, warranting exclusion) and (2) an expert whose methodological choices reflect a "fact [dispute] over which reasonable minds can differ" (the Willis Electric situation, left to the jury). The opinion also deploys EcoFactor's own language about "approximation and uncertainty" as a shield rather than a sword, embedding it within a historical survey of reasonable royalty doctrine stretching back to Dowagiac Manufacturing Co. v. Minnesota Moline Plow Co., 235 U.S. 641 (1915), and even a 1960 Columbia Law Review student note. Recovery in Patent Infringement Suits, 60 Colum. L. Rev. 840 (1960).


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Seven Patent Issues from 2025 that Deserve Ongoing Consideration

by Dennis Crouch

This week I'm delivering a talk on Patent Law issues from 2025.  The year has been defined by institutional upheaval, including the the effective shutdown of new inter partes review institutions and a USPTO willing to fill doctrinal voids that Congress and the courts have left open. The following are seven issues that I think deserve ongoing consideration. 


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Proven Infringement, Zero Recovery: Federal Circuit Once Again Cancels a Jury Verdict for the Patentee

In Rex Medical, L.P. v. Intuitive Surgical, Inc., No. 2024-1072 (Fed. Cir. Oct. 2, 2025), we find yet another decision involving the Federal Circuit overturning a jury's damages verdict.  A jury had awarded $10 million for the infringement that was reduced to nominal damages of $1.

Key holdings:

  1. Nominal damages are proper - The Patent Act sets a "reasonable royalty" damages floor, but only if there is an evidentiary basis.
  2. Comparable-license apportionment is mandatory - when a comparable license covers more than simply the patent at issue, additional evidence must be presented to the jury to explain how to apportion the license value between the patent at issue in the case, and the other rights licensed.
Click to see images from the patents (kind of gross).
Patent image 1 Patent image 2

There is a lot to question about this decision, but ultimately I think it comes down to the statement that Intuitive's attorney made at oral arguments:

Melanie L. Bostwick: This is not in the record because Rex didn't do its job in present this evidence.

Background: Days before trial, District Judge Maryellen Noreika excluded Rex's damages expert Douglas Kidder from testifying about the key comparable license in the case—a $10 million settlement agreement between Rex and Covidien that covered not only the '650 patent at issue, but also a related patent that had been the subject of a lawsuit (the '892 patent), eight other U.S. patents, seven U.S. patent applications, and nineteen foreign patents or applications. The district court found that Kidder had failed to adequately apportion the license payment among all these patents, rendering his methodology unreliable.

Trial moved forward without expert testimony.  The jury was provided the prior license and heard testimony from Rex's president Lindsay Carter, who had negotiated the prior license.  Intuitive cross examined Carter, but did not provide any witnesses  or other evidence to prove no damages or a lower damages amount.  Intuitive had been prepared to call its own damages expert (Todd Schoettelkotte), who had opined that a reasonable royalty would have been about $1–1.6 million.   The Jury ultimately found infringement and awarded $10 million in damages.

On post-trial motions, the district court granted judgment as a matter of law reducing the damages award to $1, finding that the jury lacked sufficient evidence to apportion the Covidien license to the '650 patent alone. The court also denied Rex's request for a new damages trial, reasoning that Rex had the opportunity to present other evidence but chose to rely on the very license the court had already precluded its expert from using. Rex appealed both the exclusion of its expert and the reduction of the jury award, while Intuitive cross-appealed on infringement and invalidity grounds.

Rex Medical, L.P. v. Intuitive Surgical, Inc., Nos. 2024-1072, 2024-1125 (Fed. Cir. Oct. 2, 2025).


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Patent Damage Arguments Move to the Supreme Court: Built-In-Apportionment

by Dennis Crouch

R.J. Reynolds has petitioned the Supreme Court to review a $95 million patent damages award that relied on the Federal Circuit's "built-in apportionment" doctrine, setting up a potential Supreme Court showdown. In R.J. Reynolds Vapor Company v. Altria Client Services LLC, Reynolds argues that the Federal Circuit effectively nullified the Supreme Court's 140-year-old mandate in Garretson v. Clark, 111 U.S. 120 (1884), that patent damages "must in every case" be apportioned between patented and unpatented features. [RJR v Altria Petition][RJR v. Altria - Appendix]

The RJR opinion released prior to the Federal Circuit's recent en banc decision in EcoFactor, Inc. v. Google LLC, 137 F.4th 1333 (Fed. Cir. 2025), and that case may be enough to warrant a new outcome (although note that EcoFactor does not mention RJR).  And, the petition for certiorari asks the Supreme Court to "grant, vacate, and remand in light of the Federal Circuit's recent en banc decision in EcoFactor."

The petition also asks a more fundamental question focusing Supreme Court precedent: "whether the Federal Circuit's "built-in apportionment" exception violates Garretson's apportionment requirement."

Meanwhile, EcoFactor has filed for an extension application so that its own petition for certiorari will be due mid-September 2025, with a likely parallel focus on the Federal Circuit's approach to patent damages expert testimony under Federal Rule of Evidence 702 and Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc., 509 U.S. 579 (1993).  A third case focusing on apportionment, Jiaxing Super Lighting Electric Appliance Co. v. CH Lighting Technology Co. (Fed. Cir. July 28, 2025), would make an interesting trio for the Supreme Court to consider.

Famed Patent Litigator Bill Lee and Stanford professor Mark Lemley recently published an influential article that provides grounding for RJR's petition. William F. Lee & Mark A. Lemley, The Broken Balance: How “Built-In Apportionment” and the Failure to Apply Daubert Have Distorted Patent Infringement Damages, 37 Harv. J.L. & Tech. 256 (2024). The article extends prior work by both, including Lee's 2016 article with Prof. Melamed. Douglas A. Melamed and William F. Lee, Breaking the Vicious Cycle of Patent Damages, 101 Cornell L. Rev. 385 (2016).


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Federal Circuit Vacates $300 Million Jury Verdict on Multiple Grounds

In a significant decision with implications for patent litigation practice, the Federal Circuit has vacated both infringement and damages judgments totaling $300 million in Optis Cellular Technology v. Apple Inc., finding multiple errors by the Eastern District of Texas that undermined the validity of the jury's verdict. Judge Prost's opinion identified four distinct areas of reversible error:

  1. Improper verdict form construction that violated Apple's Seventh Amendment right to jury unanimity,
  2. Incorrect patent eligibility analysis under 35 U.S.C. § 101,
  3. Erroneous means-plus-function determination under 35 U.S.C. § 112 ¶ 6, and
  4. Abuse of discretion in admitting prejudicial settlement evidence under Federal Rule of Evidence 403.

Optis asserted several standard-essential patents (SEPs) covering Long-Term Evolution (LTE; aka 4G) technology against various Apple devices including iPhones, iPads, and Watches. After an initial jury verdict awarding $506.2 million, the district court granted a new trial on damages only, finding that the jury had not heard evidence regarding Optis's FRAND (fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory) licensing obligations. The second jury awarded $300 million as a lump sum for past and future sales.

Competing jury form proposals (patentee in green; accused in blue): 

Single Broad Verdict Form from Judge Gilstrap

How Much is Hidden in the Jury Black Box: Patent cases are extremely complicated. And, this one involved five separate patents, including allegations of both literal and DOE infringement, willful infringement, and invalidity. In situations like this, district court judges look for ways to simplify the jury decision making. Judges often have legitimate concern that lay jurors will be overwhelmed by highly technical claim constructions and complex infringement theories across multiple patents, potentially leading to decisions based on confusion rather than careful consideration of the evidence. And, judges worry that overly detailed verdict forms increase the risk of logically inconsistent findings, which can complicate post-trial proceedings and create appellate complications.


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

The Remedies Remedy is Almost Complete: EcoFactor v. Google

by Dennis Crouch

The Federal Circuit’s en banc decision in EcoFactor v. Google marks a significant tightening of standards for admitting patent damages expert testimony. The court (in an 8–2 split) overturned a $20 million jury award by excluding the patentee’s expert evidence as insufficiently reliable under Federal Rule of Evidence 702 and Daubert. Writing for the majority, Chief Judge Moore treated what traditionally might have been viewed as a factual dispute over “comparable” license agreements as, instead, a matter of contract interpretation for the court. In doing so, the majority held that the trial judge failed in his gatekeeping duty by allowing the jury to hear an expert opinion founded on speculative leaps—namely, the assumption that prior licensees agreed to a particular royalty rate that was not reflected in the actual license terms. Two dissenting judges (Judges Reyna and Stark) each criticized the court for overstepping the proper scope of Rule 702 and for usurping the jury’s role in weighing evidence.  As I discuss below, I believe that the dissents have the better view of this case.  [Read the Decision]

I see this case as part of a crafted doctrinal transformation that I call the “Remedies Remedy,” that began with the Supreme Court’s undermining of injunctive relief in eBay Inc. v. MercExchange, L.L.C., 547 U.S. 388 (2006) and was then followed by a series of Federal Circuit decisions tightening the requirements for proving monetary damages. For example, the court abolished the old 25% rule of thumb for royalties as arbitrary and unreliable (Uniloc USA, Inc. v. Microsoft Corp., 632 F.3d 1292 (Fed. Cir. 2011)), reinforced the requirement to apportion damages to the patented feature’s value (LaserDynamics, Inc. v. Quanta Computer, Inc., 694 F.3d 51 (Fed. Cir. 2012)), and demanded closer scrutiny of “comparable” license agreements used as benchmarks (Lucent Techs., Inc. v. Gateway, Inc., 580 F.3d 1301 (Fed. Cir. 2009); ResQNet.com, Inc. v. Lansa, Inc., 594 F.3d 860 (Fed. Cir. 2010)). The thrust of these cases is a clear message: patent damages must be grounded in sound economic reasoning and actual evidence, not rules of thumb or tenuous analogies.  And, without sufficient expert testimony, juries will not be permitted to hear the evidence. (more…)

EcoFactor v. Google: Quick Review of Oral Arguments

The Federal Circuit recently heard oral arguments in the much-anticipated en banc review of EcoFactor, Inc. v. Google LLC, a case focusing on how courts evaluate expert testimony on patent damages.  And, in particular, when a court should step-in to bar expert testimony that does not have sufficient factual basis for its conclusions.  The arguments focused on whether EcoFactor's damages expert improperly derived royalty rates from license agreements that contained performative non-binding "whereas" clauses stating EcoFactor's belief about rates, while the operative provisions specified lump-sum payments.  It seems clear to me that these provisions were added as elements of the patentee's smaller license agreements in order to later be used in larger cases, such as the one against Google.

Judge Alan Albright (W.D.Tex.) admitted testimony from EcoFactor's damages expert, David Kennedy, who derived a per-unit royalty rate from three prior EcoFactor settlement agreements to calculate a $20 million damages award against Google for infringing EcoFactor's smart thermostat patent, U.S. Patent 8,738,327.


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Is Google Simply Asking for More Efficient Infringement?

by Dennis Crouch

Three new amicus briefs were recently filed supporting EcoFactor in the pending en banc case against Google over patent damages methodology.

The briefs - one from Law Professor Michael Risch along with a group of patent trial attorneys and another from the Alliance of U.S. Startups and Inventors for Jobs (USIJ) argue that Google's position - further limiting expert damages testimony - threatens to undermine core aspects of patent damages law while potentially violating the Seventh Amendment's right to a jury trial.  The third brief, filed by Professor Gregory Dolin argues that Judge Newman - who the court "temporarily" suspended in 2023 - should be permitted to sit on the en banc panel.  (I put "temp" in scare quotes because it appears that this suspension is - in fact - permanent).


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Federal Circuit Affirms $95 Million Verdict in E-Cigarette Patent Battle Between Altria and Reynolds

by Dennis Crouch

The Federal Circuit's December 19, 2024 decision in Altria (Philip Morris) v. R.J. Reynolds offers important guidance on patent damages methodology while potentially previewing issues soon to be addressed en banc in EcoFactor v. Google. The case centered on Reynolds' VUSE Alto e-cigarette product and its infringement of three Altria patents. U.S. Patent Nos. 10,299,517, 10,485,269, and 10,492,541.  While the court addressed multiple issues, I want to focus here on the damages analysis - particularly regarding comparable licenses and apportionment. Although the case is non-precedential, it includes both a majority opinion (authored by Judge Prost and joined by Judge Reyna) and a dissent (by Judge Bryson).  Like Judge Reyna's decision in EcoFactor, the case involves the use of lump-sum licenses to create a running royalty calculation, as well as the proper approach to apportioning damages so that the award is for the use of the patented invention.

The damages dispute focused primarily on how Altria's expert derived a 5.25% royalty rate from comparable license agreements, particularly a license between Fontem and Nu Mark. Under this agreement, Nu Mark paid Fontem a $43 million lump sum for rights to practice Fontem's patents through 2030. Following established precedent from Lucent Technologies, Inc. v. Gateway, Inc., 580 F.3d 1301 (Fed. Cir. 2009), Altria's expert analyzed Nu Mark's sales projections to convert this lump-sum payment into an effective royalty rate. The expert identified projections showing that a 5.25% royalty applied to sales from 2017 to 2023 would yield approximately $44 million in payments - close to the actual $43 million lump sum paid.


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Invisible Hand of Patent Licensing: EcoFactor and the Market Realities of Partially Performative Pricing and Lump Sum Licenses

by Dennis Crouch

In a terse order issued December 4, 2024, the Federal Circuit significantly narrowed the scope of the pending en banc review in EcoFactor, Inc. v. Google LLC, rebuking Google for its opening brief that strayed well beyond the court’s limited grant of en banc review. The order specifically targets pages 41-58 of Google’s 61-page brief—the entire section addressing apportionment of patent damages—and instructs EcoFactor not to address those arguments in its response. Going forward, the case now focuses on an expert’s use of prior license agreements as evidence of reasonable royalty damages, particularly when those agreements involve a different payment calculation approach (lump-sum vs royalties) and “performative” clauses crafted with an eye toward future litigation. (more…)

Damages Experts Analysis on the Front Burner: How Much Analysis is Enough for the Hypothetical Negotiation?

by Dennis Crouch

The Federal Circuit's pending en banc review in EcoFactor v. Google is heating up, to address fundamental questions about the reliability standards for expert damages testimony in patent cases. The case highlights growing tensions between robust judicial gatekeeping under Federal Rule of Evidence 702 and the Constitutional right to a jury determination of all facts at issue.  At base, Google is seeking to create additional  procedural hurdles and appeal off-ramps that help them avoid large damage awards.

In its en banc order, the court directed the parties to brief whether the district court properly applied Rule 702 and Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, 509 U.S. 579 (1993) in admitting testimony from EcoFactor's damages expert deriving a per-unit royalty rate from portfolio license agreements. The case presents a critical opportunity for the Federal Circuit to clarify when damages theories "cross the line" from permissible approximation to unreliable speculation.

Google has now filed its opening brief, arguing that EcoFactor's damages testimony failed to meet Rule 702's reliability standards in two key respects: its use of portfolio license "whereas" clauses that contradicted the operative terms of the agreements and its unsupported assumption that various "pressures" on the royalty rate would offset each other. The brief emphasizes that these methodological flaws rendered Kennedy's opinions purely speculative and therefore inadmissible under both Daubert and the recently amended FRE Rule 702.


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

SPEX v. Western Digital: $316 Million Verdict for Means Plus Function Claim

A Central District of California jury has awarded SPEX Technologies nearly $316 million in damages against Western Digital for infringement of a patent related to hardware encryption technology. The verdict, handed down on October 18, 2024, comes after an eight-year legal battle and raises interesting questions about infringement of means-plus-function claims and the calculation of reasonable royalty damages.

SPEX Verdict


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Federal Circuit Slices Through Patent Infringement Verdict: A Damage Apportionment Preview

The Federal Circuit recently issued a decision in Provisur Technologies, Inc. v. Weber, Inc., No. 23-1438 (Fed. Cir. Oct. 2, 2024), partially reversing a $10.5 million jury verdict in a patent infringement case involving food processing machinery. This decision marks the latest chapter in an ongoing legal battle between the two food processing equipment manufacturers. The case has a complex procedural history, including parallel inter partes review (IPR) that is now on petition to the U.S. Supreme Court.

This October decision covers some of the ground that the court may address in the upcoming en banc rehearing of EcoFactor v. Google, offering some foreshadowing of likely outcomes. Here, the court strongly sided with the accused infringer in requiring particularized apportionment related evidence before allowing a patentee to use the entire market value of a product as the royalty base.  In EcoFactor, the court will similarly focus on the evidentiary standard required of expert testimony on damages apportionment. Provisur was authored by Chief Judge Moore, one of the most 'pro patentee' judges -- signaling that patent owners are unlikely to smile when they read the EcoFactor decision.


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Guest post by Prof. Holbrook: Extraterritoriality and Patent Damages Under § 271(a)

Guest post by Tim Holbrook. Robert B. Yegge Endowed Distinguished Professor of Law and Provost's Professor, University of Denver Sturm College of Law.

United States patents are generally territorial.  Their exclusive rights only operate within the United States and its territories.  Or so one may think reading the Patent Act.  Moreover, in a global marketplace, the territorial nature of intellectual property rights can create challenges. It would be simpler for a patent holder to just use the U.S. patent to cover foreign activity. This is especially true if a domestic act of infringement has spillover effects into other countries.

So, when – if ever – can a patent owner receive damages for foreign activity that may flow from acts of domestic infringement?

The Supreme Court answered that question  


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Reviving the Permanent Injunction Inquiry: Federal Circuit Rejects a Categorical Rule Against Injunctions for Licensing Patentees

by Dennis Crouch

In a nonprecedential disposition issued March 20, 2024, the Federal Circuit vacated a district court's denial of a permanent injunction to a patent owner, finding the lower court read Federal Circuit precedent too broadly to categorically preclude injunctions in situations where a patentee has a history of licensing the patent to third parties. In re California Expanded Metal Products Co., No. 2023-1140 (Fed Cir. Mar. 20, 2024). The decision reaffirms that the equitable framework laid out by the Supreme Court in eBay Inc. v. MercExchange, L.L.C. requires a case-by-case analysis of irreparable harm and the other injunction factors, even when the patentee's business model relies on licensing revenue rather than direct competition in practicing the patents. 547 U.S. 388, 391 (2006).  However, the decision may well be seen simply as distinguishing between exclusive and non-exclusive licensing approaches.

In its decision, the Federal Circuit also affirmed the district court's R.59(e) order setting aside the damages verdict -- meaning that although the patentee proved infringement, it will receive $0 in compensatory damages.


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.