Tag Archives: Non-Practicing Entities

NPEs, patent assertion entities

Categorical Rules Cut Both Ways: Originalist Equity, NPE Status, and the Symmetry of eBay’s Four-Factor Test

by Dennis Crouch

Collision Communications, Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 2:23-cv-00587-JRG (E.D. Tex. May 17, 2026)

I previously wrote about this case when the permanent injunction was pending. Judge Gilstrap has now denied the motion, but the opinion also indicates some instances when non-practicing entities (NPEs) could block ongoing infringement.

Judge Gilstrap's opinion takes a middle ground.

  • It rejects the categorical rule Collision sought, that ongoing patent infringement presumptively constitutes irreparable harm as a matter of law under 18th-century Chancery practice (as reinterpreted through Trump v. CASA, 606 U.S. 831 (2025)).
  • And it also rejects Samsung's opposite position, that a non-practicing patent owner cannot establish the harms required under eBay Inc. v. MercExchange, L.L.C., 547 U.S. 388 (2006).

The first two eBay factors are typically the most important: irreparable harm and inadequacy of monetary relief.  Here, the court found that Collision proved both of those, but failed on the trailing two: balance of hardships and public interest.  With the result of the injunction being denied.

Although not a party, the USPTO/DOJ filed briefing (a statement of interest) in the case arguing that non-practicing patent owners should not be categorically barred from injunctive relief, and that the inherent difficulty of valuing patents and calculating damages can itself support a finding of irreparable harm under certain circumstances. The government at the same time declined to endorse Collision's more aggressive theory that ongoing infringement constitutes irreparable harm as a matter of law under 1789 equity principles. Ultimately, Judge Gilstrap appears to have adopted the government suggestions.

Despite denying injunctive relief, the key passage from the decision is the court's flat rejection of any NPE carve-out: "this Court rejects the position that a non-practicing entity can never establish irreparable harm. . . . The USPTO does not issue patents with a gold seal if the holder practices the patents, but issues patents with only a silver seal when they do not." A non-practicing patentee can satisfy the eBay factors, the court held, even if it usually will not.


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Marked for Trouble: Settlement Licenses and the § 287 Trap for NPEs

The Federal Circuit heard oral argument this morning in VDPP, LLC v. Volkswagen Group of America, Inc., No. 24-2226 (Fed. Cir. Apr. 9, 2026), and it did not go well for appellant's counsel William Ramey. All three panelists, Chief Judge Moore, Judge Lourie, and Judge Cunningham, pressed Ramey hard on a patent-marking issue, the sanctions findings, and even whether Ramey himself had properly appealed the sanctions order entered against him personally. Still, the case has an interesting doctrinal question: when a patentee settles infringement litigation through license agreements in which the licensee denies infringement, does that settlement trigger the marking obligation of 35 U.S.C. § 287(a)?


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Intitled to Tie Him Up: Can 18th-Century Chancery Practice Restore Patent Injunctions?

by Dennis Crouch

Two centuries before Samsung put 4G/5G receiver algorithms into its Galaxy smartphones, the Lord Chancellor was granting injunctions to stop patent infringement in England's Court of Chancery. That historical practice is now at the center of a(nother) frontal challenge to the post-eBay injunction framework, with the U.S. government weighing in for a third time to support NPE access to injunctive relief.

On February 27, 2026, Judge Gilstrap of the Eastern District of Texas received two filings in Collision Communications, Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 2:23-cv-00587-JRG (E.D. Tex.): a Statement of Interest from the DOJ Antitrust Division and USPTO supporting injunctive relief for non-practicing patent owners, and Collision's own motion for a permanent injunction that goes much further than the government's position. The Collision argues that the Supreme Court's 2025 decision in Trump v. CASA, Inc., 606 U.S. 831 (2025) offers the opportunity to revisit seemingly settled law -- particularly that case requires courts to apply 18th-century Chancery practice when evaluating the eBay four-factor test.  And, historians suggest that if that history is examined then the result will be a presumption that ongoing patent infringement is irreparable harm as a matter of law. If Judge Gilstrap accepts this argument, it would effectively reverse two decades of Federal Circuit precedent limiting NPE injunctions.

In my mind, the question is largely whether the Supreme Court is genuinely committed to recovering the historical principles of equity or instead invoking that history as a tool to reach today's policy goals.

Read the briefs here:


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Marking Minefield: How NPE Settlements Can Kill Back Damages

by Dennis Crouch

The Federal Circuit has affirmed an exceptional case finding and attorney fee award against Ortiz & Associates in its patent infringement action against Vizio. Ortiz & Associates Consulting, LLC v. Vizio, Inc., No. 2024-1783 (Fed. Cir. Dec. 17, 2025) (nonprecedential). Writing for the panel, Judge Bryson found no abuse of discretion in the district court's determination that the case "stands out from others" under Octane Fitness, LLC v. ICON Health & Fitness, Inc., 572 U.S. 545 (2014).

The decision also raises (but doesn't decide) an underdeveloped issue involving NPE litigation and patent marking.

The Patent Marking Statute Many of us are familiar with products marked as PATENTED and then listing the patent number. Patent marking allows a patentee to provide constructive notice and thus permits collection of back damages for up to six years. Under 35 U.S.C. 287(a), "[i]n the event of failure so to mark, no damages shall be recovered by the patentee in any action for infringement, except on proof that the infringer was notified of the infringement and continued to infringe thereafter." A huge caveat to the rule is that back damages are permitted without notice in situations where there is no product to be marked. This is typically the case for non-practicing entity (NPE) litigation where the plaintiff's key asset is the patent. But, the NPE status goes away once the patent is licensed, which is the common result of patent litigation settlement.

To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Idaho’s Anti-Troll Law Takes Aim at Federal Court Complaints: Federal Circuit Punts on Preemption

by Dennis Crouch

The Federal Circuit dismissed an interlocutory appeal in Micron Technology, Inc. v. Longhorn IP LLC, No. 2023-2007 (Fed. Cir. Dec. 18, 2025), finding no appellate jurisdiction over a district court order imposing an $8 million bond under the Idaho Bad Faith Assertions of Patent Infringement Act. This jurisdictional ruling delays what promises to be a consequential showdown over federal preemption.

Roughly thirty states have anti-patent-troll legislation -- mostly targeting bad faith demand letters.  But, Idaho's is one of the more aggressive because it identifies filing a complaint (i.e., filing the lawsuit) as a potentially unlawful communication. That choice puts Idaho on direct collision course with federal patent law in ways that other state statutes have more carefully avoided.  The problem is that patent law (supported by the U.S. Constitution) gives patentees the right to sue infringers for infringement.  Under Federal Circuit precedent, state laws that impose liability based on patent enforcement activity are generally preempted unless the patent holder's assertions were objectively baseless and made in subjective bad faith.

The appellants in this case, Longhorn IP and Katana Silicon Techs, argued that Idaho's attempt to regulate federal court pleadings is facially preempted because such filings are governed by federal patent law.  Micron and the State of Idaho responded that the state has the right and power to regulate bad-faith patent assertions, regardless of whether the assertion appears in a demand letter or a complaint. I listened in on the oral arguments and noted that the panel spent considerable time probing these questions.  But, the court ultimately concluded it lacked appellate jurisdiction. So, we'll have to wait until final judgment we receive a clear appellate answer.  And, it means that the patentee will need to pay the $8 million bond if it wants the infringement litigation to move forward.

More background:

Federalism on Trial: Idaho’s Attempt to Regulate Patent Litigation


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Federalism on Trial: Idaho’s Attempt to Regulate Patent Litigation

by Dennis Crouch

Micron v. Longhorn IP, Appeal No. 2023-2007 (Fed. Cir. 2025)

This interesting pending case focuses on an Idaho state law  regulating patent trolls. Idaho Code § 48-1703(1).

"It is unlawful for a person to make a bad faith assertion of patent infringement in a demand letter, a complaint or any other communication."

Back in 2022, Katana, an affiliate Longhorn, sued Micron for patent infringement in the W.D.Tex. Micron responded in two ways: it asserted a counterclaim under Idaho's statute in the Texas case and, one month later, filed a separate Idaho action against Longhorn under the same theory. The cases were later consolidated in Idaho, and Judge David Nye ordered Longhorn or Katana to post an $8 million bond under the Idaho law before the case could move forward.  In the process, Judge Nye upheld the Idaho law against preemption and First Amendment (petition the government) challenges and also found a "reasonable likelihood" of bad faith assertion by Katana. The case is now on appeal before the Federal Circuit with oral arguments held recently before Judges Lourie, Schall, and Stoll.

Idaho is the only state whose anti-troll statute expressly regulates complaints filed in federal court. Most states, including Vermont, explicitly exclude litigation conduct from their statutes. Vt. Stat. Ann. tit. 9, § 4197(a). Idaho's statute also authorizes an uncapped bond when a target shows "reasonable likelihood" of bad faith, without requiring findings equivalent to either the Federal Circuit's established standard for bad faith assertion liability which requires objective baselessness plus subjective bad faith.  See also, Professional Real Estate Investors, Inc. v. Columbia Pictures Industries, 508 U.S. 49 (1993) (sham litigation test).


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Back to 1789: How Founding-Era Equity Could Resurrect NPE Injunctions

by Dennis Crouch

The pending Radian Memory case could fundamentally reshape patent litigation.  This is a follow-on article about the preliminary injunction motion in Radian Memory v. Samsung pending before Judge Gilstrap in the Eastern District of Texas. The patentee-plaintiff is a non-practicing entity -- but still argues that it has a right to injunctive relief based upon traditional equitable principles, even under the requirements of eBay. In June, the DOJ and USPTO filed a statement of interest in the case supporting the availability of injunctive relief as pro-competitive. Both sides have now provided additional arguments with a July 16 evidentiary hearing scheduled. Radian particularly argues that the recent Supreme Court cases of Trump v. CASA, Inc., 24A884, 602 U.S. ___ (June 27, 2025) and Mahmoud v. Taylor, 24-297, 602 U.S. ___ (June 27, 2025), reaffirm that the key source of law should be founding-era equity practices. The key sticking point for NPE injunctive relief is irreparable harm -- and Radian's point is that the founding era cases are clear that ongoing infringement of a property right inherently causes irreparable harm.

Radian’s argument has some legs -- and would be a major transformation if successful.  Almost certainly, the “principles of equity” in 35 U.S.C. §â€Ŋ283 incorporate the historical practices of English Chancery and the Founding era.  Although eBay has been read as eliminating any presumption of irreparable harm due to ongoing infringement, that result is only implied by the case. eBay itself made historical errors that make it difficult to know whether the court intended to apply a straight historical analysis, or one that is more fictionalized.


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

U.S. Government: NPEs Deserve Injunctive Relief when their Patents Are Infringed

by Dennis Crouch

I learned of this significant development from Michael Shapiro's Bloomberg article reporting that the U.S. government took the unusual step of filing a statement of interest in a district court patent case, urging consideration of preliminary injunctive relief for a non-practicing entity (NPE). Radian Memory Systems LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 2:24-cv-1073 (E.D. Tex. 2025). The June 24, 2025 filing represents a notable intervention by both the Department of Justice Antitrust Division and the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office in what is part of its "America First Antitrust Enforcement" efforts.

Read the documents:


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Traditional Principles of Equity Acknowledge that Ongoing Infringement is an Irreparable Harm

by Dennis Crouch

The Supreme Court's landmark decision in eBay v. MercExchange dramatically changed the patent landscape by eliminating the potential of injunctive relief for many patent holders, even in the face of ongoing infringement. The Patent Act indicates that injunctions may be awarded "in accordance with the principles of equity," 35 U.S.C. 283, and in eBay, the Court found this required usage of a "four-factor test historically employed by courts of equity."  The central factor in the test for permanent relief is whether the infringement constitutes irreparable harm against the patent holder.  Prior to eBay, courts had seen infringement as indicative of irreparable harm, but altered their approach after eBay so that today a judgment of infringement comes with no presumption or indication that those tortious acts constitute irreparable harm.

A recently filed appeal before the Federal Circuit seeks to alter this new status quo -- particularly by providing an extensive historical analysis of how traditional courts of equity analyzed irreparable harm in the context of injunctive relief.  The new case is at the preliminary injunction stage, but the preliminary injunction test includes the same irreparable harm clause.


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

ITC Patent Jurisdiction: Roku’s Petition and Contreras’ Critique

by Dennis Crouch

Roku, Inc. has asked the Supreme Court to review 2024 Federal Circuit decision affirming the US International Trade Commission's (ITC) finding of a Section 337 violation based on infringement of a TV-remote patent owned by Universal Electronics, Inc. (UEI). US10593196 (method of configuring user interfaces on home theater devices to control other appliances).

The petition focuses on the ITC's "domestic industry" requirement, and the level of nexus required between substantial domestic investment, the scope of the asserted patent, and any articles that embody the patented invention.  The case invites a broader reconsideration of the ITC's role in patent disputes, including its near-automatic issuance of exclusion orders against adjudged infringers.


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

The Phantom Menace: Federal Circuit Upholds Judge Connolly’s Investigative Powers Even After Dismissal

by Dennis Crouch

In Backertop Licensing LLC v. Canary Connect, Inc., the Federal Circuit addressed the scope of a district court's inherent authority to investigate potential litigation misconduct. Chief Judge Connolly of the District of Delaware had initiated an inquiry into dozens of patent infringement cases filed by plaintiff LLCs associated with IP Edge, a patent monetization firm, and Mavexar, an affiliated consulting shop. The district court was concerned that the real parties in interest may have been concealed, that fictitious patent assignments were filed with the USPTO to shield those parties from liability, and that the plaintiff LLCs' attorneys may have violated the Rules of Professional Conduct by taking direction from Mavexar without their formal-clients' informed consent.


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.