Tag Archives: Declaratory Judgment

DJ jurisdiction, MedImmune

No Do-Overs: Federal Circuit Blocks Dismiss-and-Refile Tactic to Restart ITC Stay Deadline

by Dennis Crouch

Voluntary dismissal: Under Rule 41(a), a plaintiff can walk away from a lawsuit before the defendant answers or moves for summary judgment, no questions asked, no permission required. The tactic gets used strategically all the time: to avoid an unfavorable ruling, to refile in a better forum, etc. Courts have generally tolerated this practice, recognizing that voluntary dismissals serve important functions in managing litigation. But, there has always been some concern about strategic over-use.  In Ascendis Pharma A/S v. BioMarin Pharmaceutical Inc., No. 26-1026 (Fed. Cir. Mar. 26, 2026), the Federal Circuit drew a line, holding that a party cannot use voluntary dismissal to restart a statutory deadline it already missed. The court affirmed the district court's denial of a mandatory stay under 28 U.S.C. § 1659(a)(2), holding that Ascendis's dismiss-and-refile maneuver could not revive the 30-day window for requesting that the district court halt proceedings pending a parallel ITC investigation.

The case arises from a pharmaceutical patent dispute between two drug manufacturers developing treatments for achondroplasia (ACH), a genetic condition that causes short-limbed dwarfism. BioMarin sells Voxzogo, an FDA-approved ACH treatment covered by U.S. Patent No. RE48,267. Ascendis filed a New Drug Application for its competing product, TransCon CNP, on March 31, 2025. The very next day, BioMarin filed a complaint with the U.S. International Trade Commission alleging that Ascendis's importation of TransCon CNP infringed the '267 patent. Ten days later, on April 11, 2025, Ascendis filed a declaratory judgment action in the Northern District of California seeking a declaration of non-infringement with the argument that its imports were within the 35 U.S.C. § 271(e)(1) safe harbor - i.e., for reasons directly related to obtaining FDA approval.

This setup with parallel ITC and district court proceedings sets up a discussion of the mandatory stay provision of 28 U.S.C. § 1659(a).  That section provides that the district court shall stay proceedings with respect to any claim involving the same issues, at the request of a party that is also a respondent in the ITC proceeding.  But, the stay mandate is only required if requested within 30 days after the district court action is filed.

In our case, Ascendis had waited more than 30 days to request a stay - it then voluntarily dismissed its DJ action without prejudice and immediately refiled a nearly identical complaint the same day for the express purposes of resetting the clock.  Apparently Ascendis realized the DJ action created a problem: once the FDA approved the drug, BioMarin could use the pending district court case as a vehicle to seek a preliminary injunction. A mandatory stay under § 1659 would protect against that occurrence.


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

The Unraveling of International Patent Comity?

by Dennis Crouch

An interesting international patent issue is stirring regarding when it is appropriate for one nation's courts to pass judgment on patents issued in other countries.  A key pending case involves Onesta IP, who has obtained a number of U.S. and foreign GPU-related patents from AMD.  Onesta argues that BMW's vehicles equipped with Qualcomm Snapdragon chips in their infotainment head units infringe the patents.  However, rather than suing in U.S. Court, Onesta sued in a Munich regional court, asserting infringement of a European patent alongside two U.S. patents (Nos. 8,854,381 and 8,443,209).  That German case is ongoing, but BMW responded by filing a declaratory judgment action in the Western District of Texas, and Judge Alan D. Albright promptly granted an ex parte temporary restraining order preventing Onesta from seeking an anti-anti-suit injunction in the German proceedings. BMW v. Onesta IP, LLC, No. 6:25-cv-00581 (W.D. Tex. Dec. 16, 2025). That TRO was extended on December 30, 2025, with a preliminary injunction hearing scheduled for January 13, 2026.  This post looks at the European jurisdictional shift that enabled Onesta's strategy, BMW's defensive response through the U.S. anti-suit injunction, and whether this changed international landscape should prompt reconsideration of the limits U.S. courts have placed on their own authority to adjudicate foreign patent claims.


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

When (and Where) Does Amazon’s APEX Create Personal Jurisdiction

By Dennis Crouch

The Supreme Court will soon consider whether to review what I see as an important Federal Circuit decision finding personal jurisdiction based solely on a patentee's use of Amazon's private patent enforcement system. In Lighting Def. Grp. LLC v. SnapRays LLC, No. 24-524 (petition filed Nov. 5, 2024), Arizona-based LDG submitted a patent infringement complaint against Utah-based SnapPower through Amazon's Washington-based Patent Evaluation Express (APEX) program.  To be clear: this is a private arbitration system that relates to selling on Amazon - it is not a federal court case.  Under APEX, Amazon notifies accused sellers who have three weeks to either participate in Amazon's evaluation process, settle with the patent owner, or file a declaratory judgment action - otherwise their listings are removed.

SnapPower sued in Utah federal court seeking a declaratory judgment of non-infringement and invalidity. However, the district court dismissed for lack of personal jurisdiction since LDG (an AZ company) had no contacts with Utah. On appeal, the Federal Circuit reversed, holding that LDG's use of the APEX system knowing it would affect SnapPower's Utah operations was sufficient to create jurisdiction there. The cert petition argues this conflicts with Supreme Court precedent requiring contacts with "the forum State itself, not the defendant's contacts with persons who reside there." Walden v. Fiore, 571 U.S. 277 (2014).


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Lovevery Argues that APEX Jurisdiction Holding Undermines Anti-Counterfeiting Efforts

by Dennis Crouch

This is my third post about SnapPower (SnapRays) v. Lighting Defense, and the Federal Circuit's holding that patentee's who use Amazon's patent enforcement process (APEX) to block infringing product sales open themselves to personal jurisdiction in the home state of the accused infringer. SnapPower v. Lighting Def. Group, 100 F.4th 1371 (Fed. Cir. 2024). In my view, the Federal Circuit has gone too far with aggressive personal jurisdiction in this case, and the patentee Lighting Defense has petitioned for en banc rehearing on the issue.

Most recently, toy-maker Lovevery has filed an amicus brief supporting en banc review.


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

The Long Arm of APEX: When (and Where) does Amazon’s Private Enforcement Mechanism Create Personal Jurisdictional

By Dennis Crouch

This case would be great for a 2L law review note.

Back in May 2024, the Federal Circuit issued an important decision holding that a patentee's use of Amazon's patent enforcement process (APEX) to target an alleged infringer's listings can subject the patent owner to specific personal jurisdiction in the alleged infringer's home state - despite no direct contacts with that state.  SnapRays, LLC v. Lighting Defense Group, LLC, No. 2023-1184 (Fed. Cir. 2024). The patentee has now petitioned for en banc rehearing, arguing that the opinion conflicts with prior Federal Circuit precedent and makes a holding that the Supreme Court at least implicitly rejected in Walden.  The case is important as APEX and other similar private sales-channel enforcement processes become increasingly popular. SnapRays En Banc Petition.

My view: The Federal Circuit erred here.


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Amazon Patent Enforcement Process Can Create Personal Jurisdiction

by Dennis Crouch

In a significant decision on personal jurisdiction in patent cases, the Federal Circuit held that using Amazon's patent enforcement process (APEX) to target an alleged infringer's listings can subject the patent owner to specific personal jurisdiction in the alleged infringer's home state. SnapRays, LLC v. Lighting Def. Grp. LLC, No. 2023-1184 (Fed. Cir. May 2, 2024).

Plaintiff SnapRays (d/b/a SnapPower) is a Utah company that designs and sells electrical outlet covers with USB ports and night lights. Defendant Lighting Defense Group (LDG), a Delaware company based in Arizona, owns a patent on outlet cover technology. In 2022, LDG initiated an action against SnapPower through Amazon's Patent Evaluation Express (APEX) program


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Licensing by Acquisition: The High-Stakes Dispute Over Whether Intel is Licensed to VLSI’s Patents

The Federal Circuit has issued an interesting nonprecedential order in In re VLSI Technology LLC, denying VLSI's petition for a writ of mandamus that sought to reverse a district court order allowing Intel to amend its answer to assert a declaratory judgment counterclaim regarding a patent license defense.

The Federal Circuit's brief order sheds some light on the standards for amending pleadings late in litigation and the propriety of declaratory judgment counterclaims in patent cases even where the underlying infringement claims have been extinguished.


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.

Covenant to not sue “at any time” terminated with the license agreement

by Dennis Crouch

The recent Federal Circuit decision in AlexSam, Inc. v. MasterCard Intl. Inc. provides a lesson into the importance of carefully drafting—and understanding—the scope of licensing terms, especially covenants not to sue.  Of importance to this case is understanding both their scope and their duration.  The second half of the post delves into the jurisdictional hook that allowed the Federal Circuit to hear this case, even though it originated as a state law breach of contract claim, as well as analyzing whether MasterCard's invalidity declaratory judgment counterclaim was truly compulsory, as required for Federal Circuit appellate jurisdiction.  The post also notes a curious empaneling of judges. 22-2046.OPINION.2-28-2024_2277625.

Background


To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.