by Dennis Crouch
Traxcell lost its 2017 patent suit against Verizon in the Eastern District of Texas, and then lost the fee fight that followed. The district court awarded Verizon attorney fees under 35 U.S.C. § 285 -- roughly half a million dollars -- and the Federal Circuit affirmed. Traxcell - represented by Bill Ramey - then filed a new lawsuit in the Western District of Texas, an independent action under Fed. R. Civ. P. 60(d)(1), asking Judge Albright to declare the fee award void. Traxcell's theory: the Federal Circuit's merits mandate in the first appeal stripped the Eastern District of power to award fees afterward. Judge Albright rejected that theory on the merits. Ramey appealed, but rather than deciding that question, the Federal Circuit vacated and ordered dismissal -- holding that the Western District never had jurisdiction over the case.
The opinion makes two jurisdictional rulings about the same lawsuit.
- The court concluded this case arose under the patent laws because it was a collateral attack on a § 285 award. As a patent case, the appeal was properly before the Federal Circuit.
- The court held that the district court lacked jurisdiction over the collateral action because the allegations fell far short of the "grave miscarriage of justice" standard for collateral attack. United States v. Beggerly, 524 U.S. 38 (1998). In addition, the appellate panel concluded that one district court cannot entertain an independent action to undo another district's judgment after it has been affirmed on appeal.
I question the first holding. As I explain below, Traxcell's challenge was about the impact of an appellate mandate on a lower court's jurisdiction, and did not directly raise any patent law issue.
And, IMO, the second holding is also wrong, at least in part, because it treats Traxcell's failure to meet the Beggerly standard for an independent action as a lack of jurisdiction - converting the merits into jurisdiction.
To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Simply log in to access the full post.












by Dennis Crouch
